Barry Melek Electric Train Sets

Flat Car Pipe

The Search for a Fuel-Cell Car

Going to work in 2030. A commuter gets into a car and turns the key. There is a faint noise of auto parts pumps and compressors. The dashboard comes to life. The motor does not actually turn over, though, until the driver presses on the accelerator. Then the vehicle moves out into heavy traffic.

Looking much like their forerunners from the twentieth-century, cars are moving so quietly that the swish of tires is louder than the purr of their electric motors. No fumes spew from exhaust pipes, just wisps of pure water vapour. No smog spoils the view of the mountains. Environmentally friendly transportation has arrived.

This journey began back in 1975 in Arizona cactus country when Geoffrey Ballard, a 43-year-old Canadian geophysicist, poked his way through a small, unkempt cement-block motel just a short walk from the Mexican border. He was looking for a cheap laboratory in which to pursue his dream of finding an alternative to the petrol-driven internal-combustion engine.

He bought the motel for $1400 and burned the filthy mattresses, but the building still stank, so he persuaded the local fire department to come for a training exercise. Watching their hoses blast the place clean, Ballard thought about the world's overconsumption of fossil fuels. Reducing it would be tough, but he'd always been tenacious.

In the energy crisis of 1973 he was called to Washington to direct research into energy conservation. His wife, Shelagh, and their three school-age sons stayed in Arizona. For six months he supervised studies of virtually anything that did not depend on oil, coal or petrol. But disillusionment soon set in. Only ideas that promised results within a few years would be funded. On a visit home in early 1974, he told Shelagh that he wanted to return to Arizona and resume his quest for a better energy technology.

Ballard thought battery-powered electric cars were the best energy alternative. A big problem was the weight of lead in storage batteries. Could lithium, the lightest metal, be substituted? He had a friend, Ralph Schwartz, a quirky engineer who had been working with lithium and sulphur dioxide.

Needing an electrochemist, they went to see Keith Prater at the University of Texas at El Paso. Prater said he lacked experience with batteries. "I don't want someone who knows about batteries," said Ballard. "They know what won't work. I want someone willing to try things that others might not."

Within six months Prater was able to isolate a key ingredient, lithium dithionite. They mixed it in a  beaker with solvents, added copper strips and charged it with electricity. Then they hooked up a torch bulb – and it glowed! Prater was ecstatic. However, a practical battery would take money to develop.

Just at that time an acquaintance was refitting a submarine in Vancouver for oil exploration. Needing a package of instruments designed, he tracked down Ballard, hired him as a consultant and soon agreed to finance a lithium battery.

That's when Ballard and Schwartz bought the rundown motel in Arizona and started to run experiments. On the weekends, Keith Prater flew in from El Paso, landing his two-seat Piper in an adjacent field. Living on pizza and beer, they worked until exhausted, taking naps on patio furniture, then getting back to the chemistry.

After two years, Schwartz bowed out. Ballard was still committed to alternative energy, but he and Shelagh were feeling the pull of Canada. Prater had met and married a Vancouver woman. So they moved operations to the submarine warehouse in Vancouver.

The project's backer eventually pulled the financial plug. But his cousin, Horace Koessler, had money. He owned a seaplane and wanted a companion on an Arctic tour. "You will have a month to persuade me to invest in the battery project," he said. Desperate for financing, Ballard took a flying course.

Their trip was a near disaster. Engine trouble and deteriorating weather forced them down on an isolated pond, and for three days they sat out torrential rains. Radio calls brought no help. Finally, Ballard hung a tarp over the engine, located the problem, straightened a carburetor linkage and got them home. Koessler put up $200,000.

Next, a smoke-detector firm injected money. By now a big, jovial engineer named Paul Howard had joined Ballard. Late on a Friday in 1979 he took a phone call. The smoke-detector firm had filed for bankruptcy, meaning Ballard's company was now in receivership.

That weekend, Prater, Howard and Ballard agreed to form a new company. Ballard was the eldest by 11 years, with a track record and excellent business contacts, but he offered them equal partnerships. "There's lots of responsibility to go around," he said. They rented a small office and called themselves Ballard Research.

For the next four years they scrambled to pay the bills, mainly selling single-use lithium batteries. The rechargeable version worked, but each recharge was weaker than the previous one, like the spring of a watch running down. Then an exciting alternative appeared.

In 1983, the Canadian military wanted a fuel cell with a proton-exchange membrane (PEM) for silent power. A fuel cell is like a battery, but better. It requires no overnight charging. It reverses the familiar secondary-school science experiment in which electricity is put through water to produce hydrogen and oxygen. In a PEM cell, a polymer plastic membrane coated with platinum separates two flat electrodes. Hydrogen flows in on one side, oxygen from the air on the other. They combine to form water and generate electricity without combustion and nasty emissions.

"A fuel cell is electrochemistry," Prater told colleagues. "It's right up our alley." Ballard got the contract and hired a technical team. Engineer David Watkins set up the lab. Danny Epp, a sailor who had worked on the submarine, did most of the day-to-day building. Ken Dircks did the testing. They bought a sample of a costly DuPont membrane developed for the US space programme. But their budget was so tight that Epp scrounged materials from rubbish bins. When he needed to make grooves on the electrode plates to channel the gases, he begged a company that sold trophies to lend him an engraving machine. In three years they had the most powerful PEM cell, for its weight and size, in the world. Watkins set up a display at an international conference in Phoenix. Hardly anyone had heard of Ballard Research, but scientists noticed the impressive results. Soon they were visiting the lab.

In 1987 entrepreneur Michael Brown read an article on fuel cells in his dentist's surgery. A few weeks later he got a tip about Ballard. Excited by the fuel cell's promise, he persuaded the Business Development Bank of Canada to join his firm, Ventures West, in a syndicate that raised $880,000.

Progress continued. The Ballard team replaced the DuPont membrane with one from Dow Chemical and left it running. To their amazement, it generated four times the previous power. As they watched, a finger-thick electric cable got so hot that copper strands began to melt and fuse. They yelled and jumped around. With this second, drastic boost in power, the electric car suddenly seemed feasible.

By 1998 Ballard Research needed additional financing. Brown and his partners decided that before they would commit more money, the Ballard founders had to bring in new leadership with more business skills.

Brown introduced them to Firoz Rasul, a 36-year-old engineer who had been marketing vice president of MDI Mobile Data. Recognizing their limitations in the world of megabusiness, Ballard founders gave Rasul an equal share of stocks as well as making him president. Rasul and Brown wrote a new business plan and raised $5 million.

To refine and market the fuel cell would mean enormous growth and at least ten years with no net earnings. Employees increased from 37 in 1989 to over 450 today. The company, now called Ballard Power Systems, changed headquarters. To raise the needed hundreds of millions of dollars, they had to establish annual targets for greater power, improved reliability, reduced cost – and meet them. And they did.

One key advanced, led by polymer specialist Alfred Steck, was a cheaper membrane, the heart of the fuel cell. Mixing novel polymer plastics, Steck's group spread them to form films, dried them in a "clean room" and put them into cells. The first membranes turned brittle and failed after 300 to 500 hours, not good enough for a commercial vehicle. The "third generation" membrane, however, just kept running. When it passed 1000 hours, they broke out a bottle of champagne. At 5000 hours, another bottle. Then 10,000 hours. More champagne. When Steck had a  shelf of empty bottles, Ballard Power Systems had its own durable, affordable membrane.

By mid-1990 Ballard wanted to put the cell into a small bus to show that it could actually make wheels turn. He had been playing tennis with British Columbia's Energy Minister Jack Davis, who said, "Give me a ‘green' photo opportunity for the premier and I will get you the funding." The province provided $2.7 million of the $4.1-million cost.

They unveiled the project in June 1993 outside Vancouver's Science World. Premier Mike Harcourt waited with Ballard and the media. Suddenly Paul Howard, who was in charge, got a walkie-talkie call from the bus. "The compressor just stopped." A small bolt – not part of the cell, but crucial – had broken.

After a stunned moment of horror, Howard orchestrated a comic-opera charade. Six Ballard workers, hidden from view, pushed the bus until it rolled silently down a slight incline towards the podium. Harcourt made a speech, then said, "Now let's go for a ride." But the crowd milled around. Reporters asked Howard one question after another. He just kept talking. There were too many people to move the bus safely, so the ruse worked. Harcourt left for another appointment. "Come back this afternoon for a ride," Howard told reporters. By then the problem was fixed.

Government and motor-company officials began to visit for test runs. Vancouver and Chicago have even put in orders for city buses. Meanwhile, California has passed laws requiring that ten per cent of all cars sold starting in 2003 be zero emission vehicles. Other American states have followed suit, creating a potential market for fuel-cell cars.

Germany's Daimler-Benz, the first major car company to experiment with a Ballard cell in the late 1980's, seized the initiative. In 1996 it rolled out a minivan powered by Ballard cells. In a series of multi-million-dollar deals, Daimler-Benz bought a 20-per-cent share of Ballard in 1997, while Ford acquired a 15-per-cent stake the next year. The three firms formed two new joint companies to manufacture and market fuel cells and drive trains for electric vehicles.

"The starting pistol in the race to produce the first fuel-cell car has been fired," says Juergen Hubbert, head of Daimler's car division. "A new era in transport is dawning."

"It's an astounding leap," says David Scott, professor of mechanical engineering at Canada's University of Victoria. "The fuel cell will have an impact on transportation comparable to that of the microchip on communications."

Ballard can barely keep up with the invitations to speak at universities. He advises students: "Do not be patient. All things do not come to those who wait. Dare to be in a hurry to change things for the better."

About the Author

Bachmann Williams BAC18963 N Flat Santa Fe with Pipe Load $27.95 This is the N Scale Santa Fe Flatcar with Pipe Load from the Bachmann. Suitable for Ages 14 and Older. NMRA wheel profile. Newly tooled loads. Individual car roadnumbers. Includes: One Santa Fe Flatcar with Pipe Load. Scale: N 1/160.

Bachmann Williams BAC18958 N Flat Pennsylvania RR with Pipe Load $27.95 This is the N Scale Pennsylvania Railroad Flatcar with Pipe Load from the Bachmann. Suitable for Ages 14 and Older. NMRA wheel profile. Newly tooled loads. Individual car road numbers. Includes: One Pennsylvania Railroad Flatcar with Pipe Load. Scale: N 1/160.

Bachmann Williams BAC18968 N Flat Seaboard with Pipe Load $27.95 This is the N Scale Seaboard Flatcar with Pipe Load from the Bachmann. Suitable for Ages 14 and Older. NMRA wheel profile. Newly tooled loads. Individual car roadnumbers. Includes: One Seaboard Flatcar with Pipe Load. Scale: N 1/160.

S P Whistle Stop 18933 Flatcar with Pipe Load Western Pacific HO $35.1 This is the HO Scale Western Pacific Flat Car with Pipe Load (#2238) from the Bachmann Silver Series. Suitable for Ages 14 and Older. Blackened metal wheels. Body mounted couplers. Nonmagnetic axles. One Western Pacific Flat Car with Pipe Load (#2238).

4 Mode Hose Pipe Water Spray Gun Sprayer for Garden Car $26.49 Description:Portable 4 Mode Water Spray Gun is ideal for garden watering and vehicle cleaning, camping, etc.The gun is made of hard plastic material, and the flexible hose is constructed of soft plastic material with nylon fabric braid jacket for comfort and durability.Adjustable head rotates between each spray mode, including FLAT SPRAY, SHARP STREAM, GENTLE SHOWER, and FULL ACTION.Reinforced 2 layer design delivers exceptionally long life for the hose and enhances the working pressure and burst strength.Easy to install, this Garden Water Gun can be mounted in seconds.Rubber connector for taps with a hole which measures approx. 0.9cm in diameter.This Pipe Water Spray Gun is great for gardener!Hose measures approx. 9.7m long, 2.2cm wide when flat.Gun measures approx. 14.5cm long, 11.8cm wide, and 5.5cm thick.Weight: 595gPackage Included:1 x Hose Water Spray Gun

Amazing Fold-a-Pipe Fits Flat In Your Wallet $6.99 You wont believe your eyes, it's The AMAZING Fold-a-Pie. Fold-a-Pipe is the worlds first emergency pipe that you can carry with you discreetly at all times. What happens when you want to smoke a pipe but you cant carry your pipe with you? We all love going to concerts, shows, clubs and bars but security at these places deters us from bringing our pipes, plus who would want to bring their beloved glass pipe out on the town? Fold-a-Pipe is your solution that is 100% guaranteed to save you in a time of need! Fold-a-Pipe is a thin stainless steel card no larger the an ordinary credit card that fits neatly and discreetly in your wallet and folds in to a fully functional smoking pipe. Fold-a-Pipe is easy to assemble and take mear minutes to fold this seemingly innocent sheet of metal in to a sturdy and powerful smoking device. Fold-a-Pipe features a built in screen so no sediment passes threw Fold-a-Pipe's over-sized bowl head. The Amazing Fold-a-Pipe will have you smoking in no time and is perfect as a back up pipe that can be carried with you at all times. The coolest thing about Fold-a-Pipe is in it's unassembled state it would never be seen to be a functional pipe. Fold-a-Pipe is reusable and strong enough to be used again and again. Fold-a-Pipe includes one Fold-a-Pipe card in a cardboard sleeve with step by step folding instructions. Fold it, Pack it, Smoke it!

Car Exhaust Pipe XB-631 $9.99 FeaturesInterface Size: 5.5 5.5 cmMount to your car gas emit tube and make it morden and fashionEasy for installation Helps reduce the noiseProtects the environmentInnovative design universal styleAdopts high quality alloy aluminiumPowered by DC 12VSilver outlookSpecial fixing mechanism suits for most types of cars

Vintage Wooden Smoking Pipe $6.99 Descriptions: Durable Smoking Pipe and can be used repeatedly for a long time;Smoking Pipe is made of high quality special materials, not contain any harmful objects;Exquisitely finished, the Smoke Pipe potentially reducing up to 25% tar and nicotineCigar Pipe Weight: 70gSize: 13.5cm in length;Cigar Pipe Figure: flat mouthCigarette Pipe Comes in a slap-up paper box for more convenient to store;

Woman Changing Flat Tire on Car $24.99 H. Armstrong Roberts Woman Changing Flat Tire on Car - Photographic Print

Vintage Smoking Tobacco Pipe $6.99 Descriptions:Smoking Tobacco Pipe is durable and can be used repeatedly for a long time;Smoking Pipe is made of high quality special materials, not contain any harmful objects;Smoking Pipe of exquisitely finished, potentially reducing up to 25% tar and nicotineWeight of the Tobacco Pipe: 87gSize of the Vintage pipe: 14.3cm in length;Figure: flat mouthComes in a paper box for more convenient to store;

BJ24 Exhaust Pipe $2.99 BJ24 Exhaust Pipe. Related Remote Control Cars And Parts: Remote Control Cars RC Trucks Remote Control Boats Cen RC Car Parts

Ridgid® - Pipe Wrench Replacement Parts $11.8 Easy-to-install pipe wrench parts & accessories. Ridgid® pipe wrench parts & accessories are guaranteed genuine. Includes replacement straps, nut as well as coil and flat spring assembly.

Black Series Pro Pipe $674.99 Vance & Hines Black Series Pro Pipe ?Pro Pipe Black is the latest evolution in the Vance & Hines 2-into-1 legacy, Complete with header and collector heat shields, as well as a shield over the first step of the megaphone, Pro Pipe Black is finished with an elegant CNC machined end cap. Broad/usable torque increase Stepped headers, larger merge collector Flat Plane 12mm oxygen sensor mounts Optional quiet and competition baffles Made in the U.S.A. Click Here for Additional Exhaust Information

Da-Lite MM-R180 180" Radius Pipe $163.99 5704 Monitor Da-Lite Da-Lite Screen Company Flat Panel Display MM-R180 MM-R180 180" Radius Pipe Mounting Pipe www.da-lite.com

Krups Pipe $1.99 Pipe

S P Whistle Stop 18953 Bachmann Trains Maine Central with Pipe Load $28.35 These popular cars from our HO line are now offered to N scale modelers with features similar to their larger scale counterparts. Road Name: Maine Central with Pipe Load. Includes flat car and load. NMRA wheel profile. Individual car road numbers. Highly detailed n scale model. Dimensions: 1.1 x 2.4 x 6.3 .

S P Whistle Stop 18958 Bachmann Trains Pennsylvania Railroad with Pipe Load $28.35 These popular cars from our HO line are now offered to N scale modelers with features similar to their larger scale counterparts. Road Name: Pennsylvania Railroad with Pipe Load. Includes flat car and load. NMRA wheel profile. Individual car road numbers. Highly detailed n scale model. Dimensions: 1 x 2.4 x 6.3 .

Honda Fit Car Exhaust Pipe $11.99 FeaturesInterface Size: 6 5.5 cmSpecific designed for Honda FitMount to your car gas emit tube and make it morden and fashionEasy for installation Helps reduce the noiseProtects the environmentInnovative designStainliess steel structurePowered by DC 12VSilver outlookNote:while assembling after the vehicles run for a first 500km-1,000km, wind a gain closely for bolts and counter-loose nuts, any time be care for any loosing matter.

Car Silver Tone Stainless Steel Tail Exhaust Pipe Muffler $12.2 Description:Adopt good quality stainless steel, Car Car Exhaust Muffler with innovative design universal style.Straight through design to increase and provide maximum airflow for your vehicle's exhaust system.The Car Stainless Steel Muffler work perfect for custom exhaust system or as a decoration.This Car Tail Muffler is easy to installation and perfectly protect the environment.Mildly increase exhausts and give driver better driving experience.Size of the Car Exhaust Pipe Muffler: ~2 3/16" x 4 11/16"x 2 7/16" (Inlet Diameter*H*Outlet Diametrer)Color: silver toneWeight: 185gPackage include:1 x Car Exhaust Pipe Muffler

S P Whistle Stop 18968 Bachmann Trains Seaboard with Pipe Load $28.35 These popular cars from our HO line are now offered to N scale modelers with features similar to their larger scale counterparts. Includes flat car and load. NMRA wheel profile. Individual car road numbers. Highly detailed n scale model. Dimensions: 1 x 2.3 x 6.3 .

Pipe $194.99 Pipe - Framed Giclee Print

Lisle 34400 Exhaust Tail Pipe Expander $115.9 Stretches all pipe including stainless steel Use with an impact wrench to quickly stretch pipes Two collet sets fit pipes from 1.625in to 2.4375in Can be used on the car The pipe stretcher is a convenient inexpensive alternative to hydraulic pipe expanders Additional collets extend range to 4.25in

7-Way Flat Pin Connector $5.99 7-Way Flat Pin Connector. Car End. Plastic.

Flat 8" TFT LCD COLOR, With Audio, with Car Adapter $639.2 Flat 8" TFT LCD COLOR, With Audio, with Car Adapter

Lionel LIO19444 Flat Car with Vw Bug $104.53 From 1998 this Flower Power Flat car with HerbieLike VW Bug is an eyecatching addition to any freight train. Made from the finest materials. Satisfaction ensured.

Audio Pipe TXXAP10BL 1200W High Power Car Subwoofer Blue $162.2 10 High Power Car Subwoofer. 120 Oz Strontium Magnet. 2.5 4Layer One Piece Aluminum Voice Coil. One Piece Inverted Candy Color Aluminum Cone. Pipe Shape Patent Cast Aluminum Basket. Dual Voice Coil (2 or 8 Ohm) Operation. Maximum Power: 1200W. Rated Power: 600W. Frequency Response: 30Hz1000Hz. Color: Blue.